Top 10 Considerations When Purchasing a Used Ship

From evaluating structural integrity and regulatory compliance to understanding the nuances of operational costs and environmental credentials, each factor plays a pivotal role in making an informed decision. This guide delves into the top 10 considerations for acquiring a used vessel, providing potential buyers with the essential knowledge needed to navigate these waters. By addressing these critical points, buyers can ensure their investment is sound, compliant, and aligned with their operational objectives, setting the stage for successful maritime ventures.

* Please send feedback/suggestions to editor @ shipuniverse.com

#1 Assessment of Structural Integrity and Vessel Condition

Overview

A comprehensive assessment of a used commercial ship’s structural integrity and overall condition is the foundational step in the purchasing process. This evaluation not only reveals the current state of the hull, machinery, and onboard equipment but also provides insights into the vessel’s maintenance history and potential future performance. Given the significant investment involved and the critical role these vessels play in global commerce, understanding the extent of wear and tear, potential damage, and the history of repairs is indispensable for making an informed buying decision.

Details

The cornerstone of assessing a ship’s physical condition lies in examining its dry-docking records, maintenance logs, and the results of recent surveys, including underwater inspections. These documents offer a detailed and chronological record of the vessel’s operational history, maintenance practices, and any repairs or upgrades it has undergone, painting a comprehensive picture of its seaworthiness and reliability.

• Dry-Docking Records: Regular dry-docking is mandatory for commercial vessels, typically every two to five years, to inspect and repair the parts of a ship that are below the waterline. Dry-docking records provide critical information about the condition of the hull, the effectiveness of anti-fouling systems, and any structural repairs or modifications that have been made. These records are invaluable for identifying recurring problems or assessing the quality of past maintenance work.
• Maintenance Logs: A well-documented maintenance log serves as a testament to the shipowner’s commitment to vessel upkeep. These logs should detail routine maintenance, unexpected repairs, and replacements of machinery and equipment. Consistent and thorough maintenance is a good indicator of a vessel’s reliability and can significantly reduce the risk of operational failures.
• Surveys and Underwater Inspections: Surveys conducted by classification societies and underwater inspections provide an unbiased assessment of the vessel’s condition. These inspections are particularly focused on identifying corrosion, hull damage, and the integrity of critical structural components. Special attention is given to areas prone to stress and wear, such as the propeller shafts, rudder assemblies, and ballast tanks. The findings from these surveys are crucial for understanding the vessel’s structural health and identifying areas that may require immediate or future attention.

#2 Regulatory Compliance and Classification Status

Overview

For any used commercial vessel, ensuring compliance with international and local maritime regulations, as well as maintaining a valid classification status, is paramount. These aspects not only impact the vessel’s operational legality but also its insurability and market value. The maritime industry is governed by a complex web of regulations designed to ensure the safety, security, and environmental performance of vessels operating worldwide. Compliance with these regulations and the vessel’s classification status provide a clear indication of its adherence to industry standards and best practices.

Details

The process of verifying regulatory compliance and classification involves a detailed review of the vessel’s documentation and certificates, ensuring adherence to key international conventions such as SOLAS (Safety of Life at Sea) and MARPOL (Marine Pollution), among others.

• SOLAS Compliance: SOLAS is one of the most important international treaties concerning the safety of merchant ships. Compliance involves meeting standards for the construction, equipment, and operation of ships, aimed at ensuring their safety at sea. This includes life-saving appliances, navigational equipment, fire protection measures, and more.
• MARPOL Convention: MARPOL is focused on preventing marine pollution from ships. Compliance with MARPOL involves regulations across various annexes, covering oil, noxious liquid substances, harmful substances in packaged form, sewage, garbage, and air pollution from ships.
• Classification Societies: A vessel’s classification status, as determined by recognized organizations such as Lloyd’s Register, American Bureau of Shipping (ABS), or DNV GL, is a testament to its condition and compliance with the technical and safety standards set by these societies. Classification societies play a critical role in the maritime industry by setting standards for the construction and maintenance of ships, conducting inspections, and issuing certificates that verify a vessel’s compliance with those standards.

The classification status not only affects the vessel’s operational legality but also has significant implications for insurance. Vessels that are well-classified tend to have lower insurance premiums due to the perceived lower risk associated with their operations. Conversely, a lack of compliance or a lapse in classification can lead to higher insurance costs, potential detentions by port state control, and even denial of access to certain jurisdictions.

Ensuring a used commercial vessel meets these regulatory and classification standards requires a thorough examination of its certificates, including the Certificate of Classification, Safety Management Certificate, International Load Line Certificate, and certificates for MARPOL compliance, among others. Buyers must also be aware of any upcoming changes in international regulations that could affect the vessel’s compliance status in the near future, potentially necessitating costly modifications or upgrades.

#3 Engine and Propulsion System Analysis

Overview

The engine and propulsion system of a used commercial vessel represent the core of its operational capabilities, directly influencing performance, fuel efficiency, and maintenance costs. An in-depth analysis of these systems is crucial for assessing the vessel’s current condition, potential longevity, and overall value. This analysis not only helps in understanding the vessel’s operational efficiency but also in identifying any imminent repairs or upgrades that might be required to maintain or enhance performance.

Details

Evaluating the engine and propulsion system involves several key considerations:

• Engine Logs and Performance Records: A detailed review of engine logs can provide insights into the engine’s operational history, including hours of operation, fuel consumption rates, and maintenance or repair events. Performance records help in assessing whether the engine meets its specified output and efficiency levels, which are critical for ensuring the vessel’s operational cost-effectiveness.
• Fuel Efficiency: Fuel consumption is a significant operating cost for any vessel. Analyzing fuel efficiency involves looking at historical data to gauge average consumption under various operating conditions. This assessment can highlight potential issues with the engine or propulsion system that may be causing inefficient fuel use.
• Retrofitting and Technological Upgrades: Understanding the potential for retrofitting the vessel with newer technologies is essential for improving fuel efficiency, reducing emissions, and complying with future environmental regulations. This might include upgrades to engine components, the installation of exhaust gas cleaning systems (scrubbers), or the integration of hybrid propulsion systems.
• Propulsion System Condition: Beyond the engine itself, the condition of the entire propulsion system—including propellers, shafts, and bearings—must be examined. The alignment and condition of these components can significantly impact the vessel’s performance and fuel efficiency. Any signs of wear, corrosion, or damage could indicate the need for repairs or adjustments.
• Compliance with Emissions Regulations: With the maritime industry facing stricter emissions regulations, assessing the engine and propulsion system’s compliance with current and upcoming standards is crucial. This includes evaluating the vessel’s capability to meet IMO Tier I, II, or III emissions standards, depending on its age and operating regions.

A comprehensive analysis of the engine and propulsion system provides potential buyers with a clearer understanding of the vessel’s operational readiness, its environmental footprint, and what investments may be necessary to ensure it remains competitive and compliant. Such an analysis is indispensable for making an informed purchasing decision, allowing buyers to accurately project future operating costs and potential return on investment.

#4 Technological Upgrades and Retrofit Potential

Overview

In the rapidly evolving maritime industry, the potential for technological upgrades and retrofitting plays a crucial role in the purchasing decision of a used commercial vessel. These enhancements can significantly improve a ship’s operational efficiency, safety, regulatory compliance, and environmental performance. Assessing a vessel’s retrofit potential requires a forward-looking approach, considering not only the current technological landscape but also anticipated advancements and regulatory changes.

Details

The assessment of technological upgrades and retrofit potential involves several key areas:

• Navigation and Communication Systems: Upgrading to the latest navigation and communication technologies can greatly enhance vessel safety and operational efficiency. This includes integrating AIS (Automatic Identification Systems), ECDIS (Electronic Chart Display and Information System), and advanced radar systems. The retrofit potential in this area also extends to satellite communications for better connectivity and data exchange.
• Emissions Reduction Technologies: As environmental regulations become more stringent, retrofitting vessels with emissions reduction technologies such as scrubbers, Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) systems, or LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas) conversion kits is becoming increasingly important. These upgrades can help vessels meet IMO 2020 sulfur cap regulations and prepare for future greenhouse gas emissions targets.
• Energy Efficiency Solutions: Retrofitting with energy efficiency technologies, like air lubrication systems, waste heat recovery units, and energy-efficient lighting, can reduce fuel consumption and operational costs. Assessing a vessel’s suitability for these technologies is essential for long-term sustainability and cost management.
• Hybrid and Electric Propulsion: The potential for retrofitting a vessel with hybrid or electric propulsion systems is a growing consideration, especially for operations in emission control areas (ECAs) or for companies aiming to reduce their carbon footprint. This analysis includes evaluating the vessel’s electrical infrastructure and spatial constraints for battery storage.
• Digitalization and Automation: Integrating digital technologies for automation and performance monitoring can lead to improved operational efficiency and safety. This includes systems for remote monitoring of engine performance, fuel consumption, and maintenance needs, as well as automated systems for ballast water management and cargo handling.

When evaluating a used commercial vessel for purchase, potential buyers should consider the costs, benefits, and technical feasibility of these technological upgrades and retrofits. The vessel’s existing infrastructure, available space for new installations, and the compatibility of new systems with existing ones are critical factors in determining retrofit potential.

Investing in a vessel with a high retrofit potential can provide significant advantages in terms of regulatory compliance, market competitiveness, and operational efficiency. However, it requires careful planning and analysis to ensure that the benefits outweigh the costs and that the vessel can achieve the desired performance improvements within the buyer’s operational and financial parameters.

#5 Cargo Handling Systems and Equipment

Overview

For a used commercial vessel, the condition and capability of its cargo handling systems and equipment are pivotal in determining its operational efficiency and versatility in cargo management. These systems, which may include cranes, pumps, conveyors, and other specialized equipment, are essential for the loading, unloading, and secure transportation of cargo. Evaluating these components not only provides insight into the vessel’s current operational capacity but also identifies potential areas for upgrades or modifications to meet specific cargo handling requirements.

Details

The assessment of cargo handling systems and equipment involves a multifaceted approach:

• Condition and Maintenance History: Reviewing the maintenance logs and repair history of the cargo handling equipment can reveal how well the systems have been cared for and any recurring issues or failures. This information is crucial for estimating the remaining operational lifespan of these systems and planning for future maintenance or replacement needs.
• Operational Efficiency and Capacity: The efficiency of cargo handling systems directly impacts loading and unloading times, affecting overall operational efficiency. Assessing the capacity of these systems, including maximum lifting weights for cranes and flow rates for pumps, is essential to ensure they meet the operational demands of the intended cargo types and volumes.
• Technological Compatibility: With the advancement of cargo handling technologies, ensuring that existing systems are or can be made compatible with modern automation and monitoring solutions is a key consideration. This includes the potential integration of digital tracking systems, automated loading and unloading systems, and advanced safety features.
• Regulatory Compliance and Certifications: Cargo handling equipment must comply with international and national safety standards to prevent accidents and ensure the safe transport of goods. This involves checking for certifications and compliance with standards set by organizations such as the International Maritime Organization (IMO) and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), particularly for vessels that carry hazardous materials.
• Specialized Cargo Handling Capabilities: For vessels intended to carry specific types of cargo, such as refrigerated goods, hazardous chemicals, or oversized equipment, assessing the availability and condition of specialized handling equipment is critical. This may include refrigeration systems, tank cleaning systems, or heavy-lift gear.

Evaluating the cargo handling systems and equipment provides potential buyers with a clear picture of a vessel’s operational readiness and its suitability for various cargo operations. It also highlights areas where investments may be needed to enhance capability, comply with regulatory requirements, or improve safety and efficiency. Understanding these aspects is vital for making informed purchasing decisions and ensuring that the vessel can meet the demands of its intended operational roles.

#6 Operational Cost Analysis

Overview

Conducting a comprehensive analysis of the operational costs associated with a used commercial vessel is essential for potential buyers. This analysis goes beyond the initial purchase price to encompass the ongoing expenses of running the ship, including fuel consumption, maintenance, crew salaries, and insurance. Understanding these costs is crucial for evaluating the vessel’s economic viability and its alignment with the buyer’s budgetary constraints and operational goals.

Details

The operational cost analysis involves several critical components:

• Fuel Consumption and Efficiency: Fuel expenses represent a significant portion of a vessel’s operational costs. Evaluating the vessel’s fuel efficiency, based on historical consumption data and the efficiency of its engines and propulsion system, is vital. Potential buyers should consider the impact of fuel price fluctuations and explore the feasibility of retrofitting the vessel with more fuel-efficient technologies.
• Maintenance and Repair Costs: The history of maintenance and repairs can offer insights into the vessel’s condition and the likelihood of future expenses. Buyers should assess the regularity and cost of past maintenance activities, including dry-docking, and anticipate potential costs for addressing any identified wear and tear or outdated systems.
• Crewing Expenses: Crew salaries, training, and welfare costs are ongoing expenses that vary depending on the vessel’s operation regions and the qualifications required for its crew. Analyzing these costs involves considering the size of the crew needed for safe and efficient operations, as well as any requirements for specialized personnel.
• Insurance Premiums: Insurance costs for a commercial vessel can be substantial, influenced by the vessel’s value, age, condition, and operational risk profile. Buyers must factor in the cost of hull and machinery insurance, protection and indemnity (P&I) insurance, and any additional coverage required for specific cargoes or operational areas.
• Regulatory Compliance: Compliance with international and local maritime regulations can incur costs, especially for older vessels that may require significant upgrades or modifications to meet current standards. This includes investments to comply with emissions regulations, safety standards, and any specific requirements for carrying hazardous materials.
• Depreciation and Resale Value: Understanding the vessel’s depreciation rate and potential resale value is important for long-term financial planning. The analysis should consider the vessel’s age, condition, and market demand for similar vessels, providing an estimate of its economic lifespan and residual value.

A thorough operational cost analysis enables buyers to make informed decisions by providing a clear picture of the total cost of ownership of a used commercial vessel. It helps identify areas where operational efficiencies can be improved and assesses whether the vessel represents a sound financial investment within the context of the buyer’s operational strategy and market conditions.

#7 Environmental and Efficiency Credentials

Overview

In today’s maritime industry, the environmental performance and energy efficiency of a vessel are not just regulatory requirements but also key competitive differentiators. For buyers considering a used commercial vessel, evaluating its environmental and efficiency credentials is crucial. This assessment helps to ensure compliance with current and future environmental regulations, reduce operational costs through improved fuel efficiency, and meet the increasing demand for sustainable shipping practices.

Details

Evaluating a vessel’s environmental and efficiency credentials involves several key factors:

• Emissions Profile: Understanding the vessel’s emissions profile is essential in light of stringent international regulations aimed at reducing maritime pollution. This includes assessing the vessel’s compliance with the IMO’s regulations on sulfur oxides (SOx), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and greenhouse gases. Buyers should consider the potential need for retrofitting the vessel with emissions reduction technologies like exhaust gas cleaning systems (scrubbers) or Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) units.
• Energy Efficiency Operational Indicator (EEOI): The EEOI provides a measure of the vessel’s fuel efficiency in relation to the amount of cargo carried and distance traveled. Reviewing historical EEOI data can help buyers gauge the vessel’s operational efficiency and identify opportunities for improvement through operational adjustments or technological upgrades.
• Ballast Water Treatment: With the Ballast Water Management Convention in force, assessing the vessel’s ballast water treatment system is vital to prevent the transfer of invasive aquatic species. Buyers need to ensure that the system is compliant with the latest standards and consider the costs of any necessary upgrades or replacements.
• Hull and Propeller Efficiency: The condition of the vessel’s hull and propeller significantly impacts fuel efficiency. Buyers should examine the vessel’s maintenance history for hull cleaning and propeller polishing, as well as any modifications made to improve hydrodynamic efficiency, such as the addition of bulbous bows or propeller fins.
• Use of Alternative Fuels and Energy Sources: The potential for the vessel to be adapted for alternative fuels (e.g., LNG, methanol) or to incorporate renewable energy sources (e.g., solar panels, wind-assisted propulsion) is an increasingly important consideration. These adaptations can drastically reduce emissions and fuel consumption, aligning with future trends in maritime sustainability.
• Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII) Rating: The CII measures the carbon intensity of ship operations and will become a critical factor in maritime operations as the IMO tightens regulations on greenhouse gas emissions. Understanding the vessel’s current or projected CII rating is important for future operational planning and compliance.

Incorporating these environmental and efficiency aspects into the evaluation process allows buyers to not only ensure regulatory compliance but also to anticipate future operational costs associated with environmental standards. Furthermore, investing in vessels with strong environmental credentials can enhance a company’s reputation and market positioning in an industry increasingly focused on sustainability.

#8 Market Evaluation and Vessel Valuation

Overview

Understanding the current market conditions and accurately assessing the valuation of a used commercial vessel are critical steps in the purchasing process. The maritime industry’s cyclical nature, influenced by global economic factors, supply and demand dynamics, and regulatory changes, can significantly impact vessel prices and operational viability. A thorough market evaluation and vessel valuation not only guide buyers in making informed investment decisions but also in negotiating prices and anticipating future market trends.

Details

The process of market evaluation and vessel valuation involves several considerations:

• Global Economic Trends: The state of the global economy, including trade volumes, commodity prices, and geopolitical events, directly affects the demand for shipping capacity and, consequently, vessel values. Buyers should assess current economic indicators and forecasts to gauge market sentiment and potential shifts in demand.
• Supply and Demand Dynamics: Analyzing the supply of similar vessels on the market and the demand for shipping services in specific sectors (e.g., bulk cargo, container shipping, oil tanker) can help buyers understand price trends and identify opportunities. Factors such as fleet age distribution, order books for new vessels, and scrapping rates also influence market dynamics.
• Regulatory Impact: Upcoming maritime regulations, particularly those related to environmental compliance (e.g., sulfur cap, carbon emissions reduction), can affect vessel valuations. Vessels that already comply with or can easily be upgraded to meet new standards may command higher prices, while those that require significant investment for compliance may see their values depreciate.
• Technical Appraisal: A detailed technical appraisal of the vessel, considering its age, condition, maintenance history, and any recent upgrades or retrofits, provides the basis for its valuation. Special attention should be paid to the vessel’s efficiency, operational capabilities, and any unique features that may enhance its marketability.
• Comparative Market Analysis: Comparing the subject vessel with similar vessels recently sold or currently listed on the market can help in establishing a fair market value. This comparative analysis should consider differences in age, condition, specifications, and market positioning.
• Expert Consultation: Engaging with maritime valuation experts, brokers, and consultants who possess in-depth knowledge of current market conditions and trends can provide valuable insights and support a more accurate valuation.

Conducting a comprehensive market evaluation and vessel valuation enables potential buyers to negotiate from a position of strength, make strategic investment decisions, and anticipate the long-term financial performance of the vessel. By understanding the factors that influence market conditions and vessel values, buyers can identify opportunities that align with their operational strategies and financial goals, ensuring a successful acquisition in the competitive maritime industry.

#9 Insurance and Risk Management

Overview

Navigating the complexities of insurance and risk management is a critical aspect of purchasing and operating a used commercial vessel. Insurance not only protects the investment in the vessel itself but also covers potential liabilities arising from its operations. Understanding the various types of insurance coverage available, the factors influencing insurance premiums, and the strategies for managing operational risks can significantly impact the financial and operational stability of maritime ventures.

Details

Key considerations in the realm of insurance and risk management include:

• Types of Insurance Coverage: Comprehensive insurance coverage for a commercial vessel typically includes Hull and Machinery (H&M), which covers damage to the vessel itself, and Protection and Indemnity (P&I), which addresses liability to third parties. Depending on the vessel’s operations, additional coverage may be required, such as cargo insurance, charterer’s liability insurance, and pollution liability insurance.
• Assessment of Risks: Identifying and assessing the specific risks associated with the vessel’s intended operations is fundamental to determining appropriate coverage levels. This involves considering factors such as the age and condition of the vessel, operational areas (including any high-risk zones), types of cargo carried, and crew competence. A thorough risk assessment helps in selecting the right insurance products and negotiating premium rates.
• Influence of Classification and Compliance: The vessel’s classification status and adherence to international safety and environmental standards can significantly affect insurance costs. Vessels that are well-maintained and compliant with the latest regulations are generally considered lower risk, which can result in more favorable insurance terms and premiums.
• Loss Prevention and Mitigation: Implementing effective loss prevention and mitigation strategies can not only reduce insurance premiums but also enhance operational safety. This includes maintaining rigorous maintenance schedules, investing in crew training and safety programs, and adopting best practices for environmental protection and cargo handling.
• Insurance Premium Negotiation: Understanding the factors that insurers consider when setting premiums allows buyers and operators to negotiate more effectively. Demonstrating a commitment to safety, risk management, and regulatory compliance can aid in securing competitive rates. It’s also advisable to work with insurance brokers who specialize in maritime coverage to explore the best options and negotiate on behalf of the vessel owner.
• Claims History and Management: A vessel’s claims history can impact future insurance premiums. Effective management of any claims, along with proactive measures to prevent incidents, is crucial for maintaining a favorable insurance profile. Keeping detailed records of incidents, repairs, and related correspondence with insurers is essential for efficient claims processing.

Properly addressing the insurance and risk management aspects of owning and operating a used commercial vessel is vital for protecting the investment and ensuring long-term operational viability. By carefully selecting insurance coverage, managing operational risks, and maintaining a strong focus on safety and regulatory compliance, vessel owners can mitigate potential liabilities and enhance the sustainability of their maritime operations.

#10 After-Sale Support and Vendor Reliability

Overview

After purchasing a used commercial vessel, the quality of after-sale support and the reliability of the vendor play crucial roles in the vessel’s operational lifespan and overall performance. Effective after-sales service ensures that the vessel remains in optimal condition, with timely access to spare parts, technical support, and maintenance services. Furthermore, a reliable vendor relationship can significantly ease the process of integrating the newly acquired asset into the buyer’s operational fleet, providing a smoother transition and minimizing downtime.

Details

Key elements to consider regarding after-sale support and vendor reliability include:

• Availability of Spare Parts: Ensuring the ready availability of spare parts is critical for maintaining the vessel’s operational readiness. Buyers should verify the vendor’s ability to provide or source genuine spare parts efficiently, potentially through established supply chains or partnerships with manufacturers.
• Technical Support and Service Network: A vendor with a strong service network can offer valuable technical support, including troubleshooting, routine maintenance, and emergency repairs. This support is particularly important for complex systems or when operating in remote areas where local service options may be limited.
• Warranty and Service Agreements: Understanding the terms and coverage of any warranties or service agreements offered by the vendor can provide additional peace of mind. These agreements can cover everything from major machinery to critical systems, offering repair or replacement in the event of a malfunction.
• Training and Knowledge Transfer: Vendors that provide comprehensive training sessions or manuals ensure that the vessel’s crew and technical team are well-equipped to operate and maintain the ship effectively. This is especially important when the vessel incorporates advanced technologies or systems that the new owner’s team may not be familiar with.
• Vendor Reputation and Track Record: Researching the vendor’s reputation and track record in the industry can offer insights into their reliability and the quality of their after-sale support. Testimonials from other buyers, industry reviews, and the vendor’s history of resolving issues are valuable sources of information.
• Continuous Improvement and Upgrades: Vendors committed to continuous improvement and offering upgrades for older vessels can help extend the operational life of the ship. This may include updates to software systems, retrofitting newer technologies, or modifications to improve efficiency and compliance.

A strong after-sale support system and a reliable vendor relationship are invaluable assets in the maritime industry, where operational efficiency and vessel uptime are paramount. By carefully evaluating these aspects before finalizing a purchase, buyers can ensure they invest in a vessel that not only meets their current needs but also is supported adequately for future challenges. This foresight can significantly impact the vessel’s contribution to the operational fleet, ensuring it remains a valuable asset for years to come.

Additional References

• International Maritime Organization (IMO): The IMO is a specialized agency of the United Nations responsible for regulating shipping. The IMO website provides comprehensive information on global standards for the safety, security, and environmental performance of international shipping.
• American Bureau of Shipping (ABS): ABS is one of the world’s leading classification societies, offering guidance and services to ensure the safety and compliance of ships and marine structures.
• DNV GL: DNV GL is an international accredited registrar and classification society headquartered in Norway. The company provides services for several industries including maritime, renewable energy, oil & gas, electrification, food & beverage, and healthcare.
• Lloyd’s Register: Lloyd’s Register provides quality assurance and certification for ships and offshore structures, helping ensure they are designed, constructed, and maintained to high standards of safety and environmental protection.
• BIMCO: The Baltic and International Maritime Council (BIMCO) is the world’s largest international shipping association, with a strong focus on providing up-to-date research, information, and guidance on maritime issues.
• Clarksons Research: Clarksons Research is a leading provider of global shipping and offshore market intelligence, offering data and analysis on a wide range of maritime sectors.